We’ve had three elite coaches in our history who were hired away. We’ve had a couple of others who were jokers and hired away because they did ok with the players from the elite coaches. Manning is somewhere in between that.
When we fired Wojcik (Skip Prosseer protege), our roster was gutted by transfers and some of the shadiest player handlers you’ve ever seen. (One player ended up with our current coach before the NBA, which is another level of weird.) It was a dumpster fire. Manning went out and found a couple of players late and then did some good things with a couple of signed players no one else really wanted. In some respects he was very lucky (Shaq Harrison and Juice Woodard).
In retrospect, other than his first recruiting class, which was made up of spare parts no one else wanted, he didn’t really do much of anything in recruiting. There was some hype, like a top 100 transfer who signed and then was gone from campus in 72 hours, but it never went anywhere. The biggest recruit he had was Wilbekin and we cut bait on him within hours of Manning leaving.
He can coach defense and was a good enough ambassador of the program. His second year we had a decent enough team in a crap league that was mad we were leaving. We spanked some teams in the conference tournament when we got hot. It was fun.
People were really into the team because it was a bunch of lowly ranked recruits who just played hard and together and because they were tougher than anyone, including the idiots that openly tried to prevent us from winning the conference. Also, at least on here, we got to stick it to the handlers, one of whom ended up with criminal charges. (There was a cinematic quality to the whole thing.)
He made it a little too dramatic when he left. It went on too long. I don’t think he should have left, but I also don’t think he had a game plan to be competitive in the American. I don’t know that coaching everyone to be tougher and meaner would have worked against UCONN and Cinci.
He had some good ideas, but I’m kind of glad he bailed when he did. He might be happier counting his money in retirement and shaking hands at KU.