Eddie Johnson scored 7 goals in his first 6 games for the USA, was soon playing in Europe in top form, and was the savior of American soccer who was going to revolutionize the game and be the catalyst for depriving the NFL and NBA of the young black talent pool upon which both depend.
2 years later, he was hurt and out of contract. 4 years on, he was the scourge of the locker room and had to work his way back on when the USA literally had no one else to turn to.
His story is not unique. Adu, Quaranta, Altidore, Bradley, Bobby freaking Convey, even to a lesser extent, Tulsa's own Joe-Max Moore. Zardes at 16 was seen as a sure thing in Europe until he had some issues and ended up at Cal State and they still said he had "mad skillz" who would be our savior. (And he did have a heckuva a highlight tape).
Pulisic has had some advantages and achievements those guys have not, most notably a set of parents with a familiarity for pro soccer and reality, but he isn't carrying the cargo of the USA hype train yet imho.
When we see German media singling him out for praise and he is a regular selection for a complete season, I'll say some of the talk is justified. Right now,
Maybe it's just 30 years of watching CONCACAF qualifiers tainting my view, but I saw a kid who made us forget a dozen turnovers with flashes of brilliance against Honduras. The 6-0 result hekped.
In Panama, he was undersized even against Central American competition. He is still a boy routinely shaped and pushed off the ball and had to resort to fouling to keep or regain possession. The quickness and speed is impressive, but that's only one move and once recognized is worthless when he is lying on the ground spitting up the pitch.
The goal set up was impressive, but there are plenty of refs in Italy or WC Final games (fairly or unfairly) who would have blown that play dead.
He is fun to watch and that is the point of the game -- to enjoy it and not view every contest as a referendum on the adequacy or failures of the American game vs Europe. So for now I view Pulisic through patient eyes, don't expect much now, because he hasn't delivered it consistently, and don't expect much later because so many before have had similar hype and disappeared.