He's 100% a left fullback. Berhalter's style is predicated on the 2 fullbacks forcing defenders wide and opening space in the middle for the creatives like Pulisic and Aaronson. (And I forgot about him too)I forgot about Antonee Robinson at left back who surely gets one of these 4 slots. He's been knicked up. And please, Beer?halter, not as a wingback pumping crosses nowhere to nobody. He's become a solid defender for Fulham & we need him on that back line.
Which also places pressure on our CBs because that high double pivot leaves acres of space. It’s insane we don’t know our backline or tactics 60 days out.He's 100% a left fullback. Berhalter's style is predicated on the 2 fullbacks forcing defenders wide and opening space in the middle for the creatives like Pulisic and Aaronson. (And I forgot about him too)
It’s worse than that. I need to watch it again and pause and rewind, but not only was the strategy and tactics poor, but the players were manipulated within those tactics. That is to say Japan was so confident in the high press and their ability to manage the wide play that they could see that Long was unable to play forward off his left and that Jesus was not saintly with his ability to win the long ball. So they took everything else away and forced Long and Zimmerman to play out of the back. Which would be fine if a) we hadn’t tried that and failed repeatedly over the last three years and b) our two best defenders who can pass out of the back aren’t even in the pool because they can’t play chalk to chalk because our coach is a simpleton committed to one strategy and naive tactics. But hey, two months before the World Cup, let’s have a guy sit and spray two touch passes against a high press because he’s playing out of position to some kid who isn’t going to make the roster. They lost possession more than 50 times in the first half. No shots the entire game. Jesus terrible back foot jumping and poor timing on the only half chance he got. If we do what we saw the other night, both Wales and England will score in the first ten minutes and low block for the remainder of the game and dare Gio to try to break us down.Oh my goodness! It looks like Beer?halter's System chickens have come home to roost. That is, I flashed back to the beginning of qualification with the "build from the back and counter attack system & him telling his players that they will keep the opponent with little of the ball & wear them out.
Then, the System came along with attacking down the channels with a wingback forward in the attack. Then, a high press System with constant pressure & attacking through the middle. And all the while bringing in new personnel looking for those "System" guys. Not to mention Beer?halter claiming that it didn't really matter what form you were in, but rather how you fit in the "System" to justify not calling up certain people.
The USA loses to Japan, 2-0. In the 1st half, everyone on the team, no exceptions, was giving away the ball with poor passes. Over twenty times. Ferreira has one shot close in & heads it well over the bar.
Yeah, I know, several of our best players are either hurt(including CP) or on the bench or NOT called up. But no excuses. This was a beatdown with Japan controlling the action & the US with zero shots on goal while "building from the back". Turner was the only player worth a flip, despite giving up 2 goals. A giveaway by Wes McKinnie led to the first, and Cannon & Vines had a great view of Japan's 2nd. If guys such as Long, Vines, de la Torre, Morris, Cannon, McKenzie, etc. happen to make the final roster for Nov., one wonders who they replace and can only hope they never get off the bench. I imagine Pepi will get the start vs Saudi. We'll see how that works out.
Huffy is obviously referring to John Brooks & Tim Ream. Yes, at their age, they are slow. But so experienced in the Big Leagues and so accurate in their passing out of the back. Do we need experience vs top competition back there and accurate passes after yesterday? Is the Pope Argentinian?our two best defenders who can pass
When I was a youth player the rule that goalkeepers could not handle back passes did not exist yet.Huffy is obviously referring to John Brooks & Tim Ream. Yes, at their age, they are slow. But so experienced in the Big Leagues and so accurate in their passing out of the back. Do we need experience vs top competition back there and accurate passes after yesterday? Is the Pope Argentinian?
Beer?halter said we needed more "personality" in our play. Huh? What we need is to dump the pretenders of the 26 called up & get the Best Players Available. Of course, it's much too late to get the best players, not the best Beer?halter system guys, together to mold them into a viable team to compete at the highest level. Yes, injuries didn't help the cause, but everyone sucked who played and the injured guys (in camp) would have made no difference.
Although Aaronson & Sargent were active, as always, they got no service. And poor Aaronson. This dude was beat to a pulp. One very hard foul deserved a straight red when the defender was late & raked his calf with a high boot.
One more thing. Not only is Beer?halter a joke as a coach, dude is a slob and an embarassment on the bench. Maybe no one has noticed, but his attire consists of a T-shirt and a 4-day growth of beard, always, and yesterday was no exception. Classless & clueless. (this post edited)
Neuer is now the standard and GKs have to be 4 tool players. Shot stopper, decision making, distribution, and 11th field player to play out of the back.When I was a youth player the rule that goalkeepers could not handle back passes did not exist yet.
Passing back to the GK was the safety valve in any pressure situation. It covered up for a lot a fundamental ball control deficiencies- including mine. And goalkeepers did not have to be too skilled with the ball at their feet. The rule came in when I was around 20 I think.
I am regularly amazed at the level of skill among central defenders and goalkeepers in the modern game.
There won’t be any changes to the lineup.Saudi Arabia tomorrow. Who will Beer?halter run out? At least Pulisic is named and Ricardo Pepi. Beer?halter wants to check him out, again, to see if he can find the net a year later. Kind of late to be looking at players, but that's part of Beer?halter's strategy. Over the wk-end, England ties Germany 3-3 but hasn't won in 7 straight. Wales loses to Poland and unfortunately, Iran beat somebody in an Asian tourney.
If Beer?halter's plan isn't working at halftime, who will demand a change in tactics? My $ is on C. Pulisic. Dude is no stranger to controversy lately. Has anyone heard about his new book out? He rips Herr Tuchel. He also snubbed some Chelsea fans and, of course, they mostly hate him now. There is talk of a move to Juventus for around $35 million, half of what Chelsea paid for him.
Whatever happens tomorrow, there needs to be numerous changes to the final line up, not to mention Beer?halter's tactics.
What's that definition of insanity, again?There won’t be any changes to the lineup
I’m sorry I was unclear. They did announce Pepi in for Jesus a few days ago. And I knew that. That is a change in the lineup. I meant no changes in tactics and game plan when I wrote that in frustration. We are at the last game of the cycle and still looking for players who can play in this system. Insane.What's that definition of insanity, again?
I was reading an article the other day that speculated that Berhalter was blowing off this WC and wouldn’t be calling up mature players such a Pefok in order to prepare younger players for the 2026 cup when North America is hosting.
If true that's just asinine. The young players he is 'preparing' won't be that much better from him calling them up.I truly and honestly hope that last nights game was some kind of disguise or misdirection on what we truly plan to do. Otherwise, this is some kind of 8 year plan with Berhalter only around for 4 years and 1 day of it.
Turner was solid. Yedlin was solid. McKennie had his moments although I think he played outside the system because he knew the system wasn't going to work with the players they ran out there.Usually one can find something good to say about 1 or 2 players' performance in a match at a minimum.
Just finished watching the Saudi match and I cannot think of a single positive observation about anyone's performance.
Even when the long passes were finding their targets early, first touches were just a little off and we lost advantage.
After watching this team's exercise in futility this past week, I understand Huffy's frustration perfectly. Beer?halter has squandered the best talent in perhaps our nation's history with his "System". Injuries didn't help to several of our top players, but you wonder if even they would have had success with this "build from the back" fiasco, IMO.I have no interest in watching this team. None.
Ream played the 3, 5, and 6 for Bolton during the time he played the 3 for the USMNT. He wasn’t “out of position.” As a practical matter we rotated to a narrow three man back line to get Yedlin forward and Bradley sitting quite often so he was even less “out of position.” It’s why he was out there at 3 in the first place.Turner was solid. Yedlin was solid. McKennie had his moments although I think he played outside the system because he knew the system wasn't going to work with the players they ran out there.
Musah seems to be the lynchpin for this group. He's the connection point between Adams and the front line attackers. He's really good technically and can beat the initial defender 1 v 1 and once that happens the US is away. I thought de la Torre could be an adequate replacement but he didn't look good against Japan. Japan of course was way more athletic than I anticipated and they really forced the issue against the US. Saudi Arabia didn't have much and seemed to play very narrow which plays into the US strength on the outside.
Does anyone think Berhalter is sabotaging certain players? I mean the game vs Saudi Arabia would have been perfect for Carrot Top to be in the middle. With Pulisic, Yedlin, and Dest finding space wide, Carrot Top and his ability to win in the air was what was needed in the middle. Pefok would have also been a great choice to be a 9 in this game. It was just weird. And I'm really worried that Berhalter has already decided that Zimmerman and Long are his starting CB pairing. This is worse than any of the combinations of Besler-Miazga. Zimmerman is serviceable as a defender but he's not the leader (IMO) a CB needs to be to organize what's going on back there. That's where a Ream becomes invaluable as it is apparent we have all underestimated him (and the fact that Klinsmann played him out of position). Same with Brooks although I believe his benching vs Honduras was warranted. He was really bad in that game. Is Berhalter really banking on Richards being back there with Zimmerman? Seems dicey considering they haven't played much together and communication and relationship between the 2 CBs is key to making that partnership work. You only get that by playing together. I think there are 3 guys I'd have back there before Long. Richards, CCV, and Ream. Also, Scally played well in his minutes yesterday. Active, solid defending, and could really get things moving forward. I am happy with the 5-6 guys on the outside (Dest, A Robinson, Scally, Yedlin, Vines, Cannon).
Reminded me of a U20 game.Yedlin had a bad giveaway in the first half but played ok otherwise. Zimmermann was ok and made some very nice long passes early in the match.
Perhaps the lack of a crowd was a factor in the low energy and intensity. It really felt like two teams scrimmaging during practice.
That cannot ever be an excuse to play poorly at this level. I'm all for players having bad days or bad matches but it should never be due to lack of motivationYedlin had a bad giveaway in the first half but played ok otherwise. Zimmermann was ok and made some very nice long passes early in the match.
Perhaps the lack of a crowd was a factor in the low energy and intensity. It really felt like two teams scrimmaging during practice.
I think Berhalter found a successful formula vs Mexico and I'd like to see that as the game plan moving forward. It was the most focused game I've seen from the US in a long time including the CONCACAF Nations Cup and Gold Cup finales.
Yep, wait till Nov 9th, and the first world cup game to see if this guy suddenly plays it differently in tourney. Not a lot of hope right now. Leopard not changing his spots and all.I will try very hard to concentrate on football and forget about futbol until Nov. 9th when Beer?halter names the final 26. I'm pretty certain the only changes will be to add the 4-5 guys that we all know about that have been hurt, with no changes to his plan of attack. At this late stage, the dude seems to be doubling down on playing his Boyz (you know who they are & I will name them if asked) as well as his System which the whole world knows how to defense.