ADVERTISEMENT

USMNT New Era

It’s happened or rumored to happen a couple of times over the last year or so.

CP clearly waved off the gaffer when he tried to pull him just prior to a direct free kick against Canada. In the replay he appears to concede the sub then sees it was going to be Tessmann coming in and waves it off. He was eventually subbed off for Tessmann several minutes later.
 
Couple things on this. Pulisic waves off the substitution but only to take the DFK. Who else is really taking that and going to be more dangerous than Pulisic? With that, it is exceedingly rare to make a substitution in that type of attack situation or on corners. I have refereed many a game where there are subs waiting to come into the game and I look and call for them and the coach doesn't want them in the particular situation and will wait for a goal kick or throw in. And I should remind everyone, the actual laws of the game say a substitution can occur on any stoppage of play at the referee's discretion. It doesn't have to be on your throw in or restart in your favor. HS and college rules are slightly different in that it has to be your throw in or corner to make that substitution.

And everyone needs to start to realize you can have five or six elite international players and they may not complement each other on the pitch. England had perhaps the best two midfielders in the world for the better part of a decade. Neither could fully service Wayne Rooney in their preferred style of play. Neither could play with the other effectively despite years of trying and unlimited coaching resources. One of them left the back exposed with his decisions and demands for freedom. It made England dysfunctional for 10 years. Great players. Bad team.
This is important to note and it is true for any team sport. You can have a great collection of talent but if they don't mesh and actual work together they're going to struggle. The biggest problem with the US right now is there is no big personality who can also be a leader. McKennie is a big personality but I've never viewed him as a leader type. ream could be that leader but you don't even know if he's going to be part of the squad going into the WC. Really, it needs to be Pulisic but he has issues getting himself pumped up for games so it's hard to see him being the guy that gets on others for not playing with enough focus and intensity. He almost sort of checks out of games if he is not able to get involved early on. Adams....maybe but he needs to stay healthy. Not Weah. Musah has the intensity but not the discipline to lead. Quite honestly, the person I constantly think of as an actual leader in terms of US players is Christian Roldan but he's not likely to be used on the USMNT again.
 
In friendlies, teams often discuss the amount of minutes each player will play in exchange for release from their club.

He was selfish for wanting the kick and it was weakly and ineptly taken imo.

it’s an indefensible and incredibly bad look for a star play to short a sub, defy a coach, and possibly frustrate the program’s arrangements with a releasing club who quite possibly has paid an insurance policy based on appearances/minutes played.

Your excuse for him ignores the obvious: if CP wasn’t defying him, then he was frustrating what Poncho was trying to do: see how the team reacts if it needs a set piece to win in a game that counts and Pulisic is hurt or suspended.

It’s spoiled bush league or low awareness. Or both.

I am almost certain Ream will have the Roldan role moving forward. But that’s a very good call by you.
 
Couple things on this. Pulisic waves off the substitution but only to take the DFK. Who else is really taking that and going to be more dangerous than Pulisic? With that, it is exceedingly rare to make a substitution in that type of attack situation or on corners. I have refereed many a game where there are subs waiting to come into the game and I look and call for them and the coach doesn't want them in the particular situation and will wait for a goal kick or throw in. And I should remind everyone, the actual laws of the game say a substitution can occur on any stoppage of play at the referee's discretion. It doesn't have to be on your throw in or restart in your favor. HS and college rules are slightly different in that it has to be your throw in or corner to make that substitution.


This is important to note and it is true for any team sport. You can have a great collection of talent but if they don't mesh and actual work together they're going to struggle. The biggest problem with the US right now is there is no big personality who can also be a leader. McKennie is a big personality but I've never viewed him as a leader type. ream could be that leader but you don't even know if he's going to be part of the squad going into the WC. Really, it needs to be Pulisic but he has issues getting himself pumped up for games so it's hard to see him being the guy that gets on others for not playing with enough focus and intensity. He almost sort of checks out of games if he is not able to get involved early on. Adams....maybe but he needs to stay healthy. Not Weah. Musah has the intensity but not the discipline to lead. Quite honestly, the person I constantly think of as an actual leader in terms of US players is Christian Roldan but he's not likely to be used on the USMNT again.
I’m not worried about personality. If anything they all seem to have decided that they are all friends and they are the ones that are going deep next summer.

They aren’t as great as they think they are. And they have inflated views of their teammates.

I think the problem is their skills just don’t always compliment each other.

Sargent can’t get service to save his life is a good example. Not that it matters. You get one chance against the teams we aim to beat and you must bury it. Sargent has shown he is pretty amazing with multiple opportunities at the club level. Hes repeatedly had games where he has only had one chance and has not taken advantage or been unlucky. Hes off my list for that reason, barring injury,

Charlie Davies after he got hurt said a player was added to the WC roster that was going to be left off because the player was in an elite league but simply couldn’t give him over shoulder service in some situations that was vital for what they were trying to do. And so other players from lower leagues were given a chance and while they could provide the service, they knew it would create problems on the back end that would catch up with them in the later rounds. Him being injured hurt the offense but improved the defense in terms of skills complimenting each other. And it may have meant they did better than if he had not had the accident.

We have a bunch of good players, but are they the best we can get when they are all together.

 
I always thought the coach had the absolute say on subs, and if a coach insisted they would force a player to come out. If it is not that way, it should be. The only time it gets in the way is when a coach's abilities are incompetent.(Phillips and the NIT come to mind.) When you give the players that much power it becomes a nightmare. Too many chefs in the kitchen. One BOSS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HuffyCane
I always thought the coach had the absolute say on subs, and if a coach insisted they would force a player to come out. If it is not that way, it should be. The only time it gets in the way is when a coach's abilities are incompetent.(Phillips and the NIT come to mind.) When you give the players that much power it becomes a nightmare. Too many chefs in the kitchen. One BOSS.
Exactly.

The look on the gaffer’s face at the end of that clip says it all.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT