Exactly. There is more to kicking than accuracy and power.
In the 80s and 90s, soccer style kickers were more accurate than the old school straight on kickers. The linemen were shorter and the rushing less sophisticated. So it made sense to give up 5 to 10 yards in power to get someone more accurate out there. So you could go troll the best goal keepers on elite soccer teams and find somebody that had the leg to put a ball into a trash can at 75 yards. Those guys were significant more accurate at 45 yards with a football than any straight kicker. Further complicating things, soccer styles have changed in the last 15 years and kids are now taught to play the ball out of the back. So you don’t have as many kids from age 10 to 18 learning how to boot the ball as far and as accurate as possible. You can get away with playing a talented (and/fearless) keeper whose kicking power is suspect if need be and many programs are doing that if the keeper is tall, has large hands, or has good instincts or leaping ability. So the pool of kids you can find on soccer pitch who can really kick is lower than it was 25 years ago.
Now, with the improvements in rush techniques, better athleticism when rushing from the edge and taller linemen, your quickness, strength, and accuracy are all distilled down into a much narrower window. A window that few people have and even with that natural talent, it takes practice and real reps. So these kids are not unicorns, but it’s hard to pick a reliable kicker out of the crowd, even with all the recruiting services and evaluation camps. It’s one of the reasons coaches try tell them to walk on andbpractice for two years. And also why a lot of parents resist that plan if their kid is scholarship worthy and they don’t know for sure based on depth that he is going to play.
In our case, our kickers just haven’t had many real reps.
It isn’t an easy process to analyze why kicks are missed. The psychology of the kicker is important but overblown. It takes years for a snapper to adjust their snap so the precise number of revolutions happens on the ball before it arrives at the holder’s hands at the precise speed necessary to avoid disrupting the kickers wind up. Precision in some cases down to the 1/8 of a revolution. Similarly, whether your holder is new to the snapper, which is the case here, can make a difference. Some like it high, others low, others it doesn’t matter. And if either kid is left handed and the kicker is a righty and never kicked with lefties the whole thing can become 6s and 7s. Angle of the kick, position of the ball on the field, near the ppponents bench or near the TU sideline, how far away the crowd is from the kick, these all affect the complex mechanics of kicking. I’ve heard visiting kickers have trouble kicking into our north end zone because the Case Center screws up their depth perception and thus their wind up to the kick.
There’s a lot more going on than just talent and even the very best often struggle early on.