I can only speak on the girls side due to boys MLS Next and the differences between boys and girls platforms.So ECNL touts itself as a great platform, and maybe the actual ECNL actually is...but I am pretty sure all these RL and RL regional leagues are nothing more than money grabs by the org running ECNL...and the clubs are morons for thinking that they may play themselves into an ECNL bid through these regional leagues. We're all debating the merits of TSC and WSA's 2nd teams even being part of these regional leagues because the competition might be too much for them. And the clubs are selling the RL league as a stepping stone to ECNL competition and showcases that could result in potential scholarships. It's all BS. Coaches will tell you they might be at those showcases but they rarely come away with more than a name or two. And at that, when they get the name they're going to invite them to their camp. Most college coaches will tell you a good many of their domestic finds come from camps either at their school or one of these specialty camps. And I'm telling you now, if you want your kid to go to a certain school and play soccer, contact the coach after the sophomore year, introduce them, send a link to their HUDL highlights, and then tell them you're coming to "x" camp and I look forward to meeting you in person. Those interactions go way farther than allowing for some chance meeting at a showcase unless you're one of those special talents that everyone knows before you get to the showcase.
But Barry and Roger Bush aren't going to tell your kid that. They're going to say "keep playing with us and we'll make sure you get seen by college coaches" which is something that should never promise because they can't assure it will happen. Sure they can say we're going to college showcases...but there have been many times we've gone to a showcase and I could count on Luke Skywalker's left hand (towards the end of ESB) how many college coaches actually showed up.
You’re spot on in most of your observations. Ecnl will promote several clubs every year to ECNL. Others are promoted from regional to ECRL. Arkansas Rising in fact moved last year. So there’s not a lot of movement between ecnl levels but there is some.
Practically zero college scouts attend regional RL games other than those who were specifically invited by individual players. There will be college coaches at ECRL national events. Mainly from the smaller schools. ECRL is a decent level of soccer. Higher than any platform other than ECNL and GA imo. ECRL girls do get scholarships. Generally lower level schools but the opportunities are there. RL- regional league players not so much.
There are college coaches everywhere at ECNL nationals. I’ve seen games at nationals with more than 40 college coaches. The clubs hand out laminated color info sheets to all coaches and scouts in attendance. Sheets have player pics, measurables, position, along with a short bio. Every coach or scout in attendance will have sheets for each team playing. I haven’t attended an older player ecnl showcase yet so I can’t speak to the coaching turnout at those.