The 2023-24 Players’ All-Pro First Team
Offense:
| Player | Position | Team |
| Lamar Jackson | Quarterback | Baltimore Ravens |
| Christian McCaffrey | Running Back | San Francisco 49ers |
| Kyle Juszczyk | Fullback | San Francisco 49ers |
| CeeDee Lamb | Wide Receiver | Dallas Cowboys |
| Tyreek Hill | Wide Receiver | Miami Dolphins |
| Travis Kelce | Tight End | Kansas City Chiefs |
| Trent Williams | Left Tackle | San Francisco 49ers |
| Joel Bitonio | Left Guard | Cleveland Browns |
| Tyler Smith | Left Guard | Dallas Cowboys |
| Jason Kelce | Center | Philadelphia Eagles |
| Zack Martin | Right Guard | Dallas Cowboys |
| Lane Johnson | Right Tackle | Philadelphia Eagles |
Defense:
| Player | Position | Team |
| Myles Garrett | Edge Rushers | Cleveland Browns |
| Maxx Crosby | Edge Rushers | Las Vegas Raiders |
| Dexter Lawrence | Nose Tackle | New York Giants |
| Chris Jones | Interior Defensive Linemen | Kansas City Chiefs |
| Aaron Donald | Interior Defensive Linemen | Los Angeles Rams |
| Roquan Smith | Off-Ball Linebackers | Baltimore Ravens |
| Fred Warner | Off-Ball Linebackers | San Francisco 49ers |
| DaRon Bland | Cornerbacks | Dallas Cowboys |
| Pat Surtain II | Cornerbacks | Denver Broncos |
| Jessie Bates III | Free Safety | Atlanta Falcons |
| Kyle Hamilton | Strong Safety | Baltimore Ravens |
